Archivepanel

How to use your website as evidence of trade mark use

A non-use challenge asks you to prove five years of genuine use. What your web pages can show, what they can't, and how to keep dated copies that answer for place, time, extent and nature.

A registered trade mark that is not used can be lost. In the UK and the EU, if you oppose a later application on the strength of a mark registered for five years or more, you can be asked to prove it has been put to genuine use. Anyone who wants it gone can apply to revoke it for non-use. Either way, the burden falls on the owner, and the evidence has to cover a five-year window that may have closed some time ago.

For many businesses the most visible use of a mark is on their own website: product pages, prices, the checkout, the brand in the header. The difficulty is that the website you can show today is not the one that was live in the window. This post covers what the law asks for, what a web page can and cannot prove, and how to keep a dated record that answers a challenge. It deals with UK law under the Trade Marks Act 1994 and with EU trade marks before the EUIPO.

Who has to prove what

In the UK, section 100 of the Trade Marks Act 1994 is short: if a question arises in civil proceedings about the use to which a registered mark has been put, "it is for the proprietor to show what use has been made of it." The challenger does not have to prove that you did not use it. You have to prove that you did.

Two situations bring this up.

Opposition. If you oppose someone else's application using an earlier mark that has been registered for five years or more, the applicant can ask you to prove use. In the UK, section 6A sets the relevant period as the five years ending with the date of the later application (or its priority date). For EU trade marks, Article 47(2) of the EU Trade Mark Regulation asks for genuine use "in the Union" during the five years before the later application's filing or priority date, and says that without that proof "the opposition shall be rejected."

Revocation. A UK registration can be revoked under section 46 if the mark has not been put to genuine use in the UK within five years of registration, or if use has been suspended for an uninterrupted five years. Article 58(1)(a) of the EU regulation does the same for an EU mark across any continuous five-year period.

Both revocation rules have a three-month proviso that makes dates matter. Use that starts or resumes in the three months before the revocation application is disregarded, unless preparations for it began before you became aware that an application might be made. A dated record showing when a page went live can be the difference between use that counts and use that looks like a reaction to a threat.

What "genuine use" means

Genuine use is not a box ticked by putting the mark on a page. In Walton International v Verweij Fashion [2018] EWHC 1608 (Ch), Arnold J summarised the Court of Justice's case law at paragraph 115. The points that matter most for website evidence:

  • Use must be "more than merely token", not use that only serves to keep the registration alive.
  • It must be "real commercial exploitation of the mark", the kind that creates or preserves "an outlet for the goods or services that bear the mark".
  • "Internal use by the proprietor does not suffice." A page that the public could not reach, or a staging site, is not use on the market.
  • Use can relate to goods or services about to be marketed, where preparations to secure customers are under way, "particularly in the form of advertising campaigns".
  • "All the relevant facts and circumstances must be taken into account", including the scale and frequency of use and its territorial extent. Use "need not always be quantitatively significant", and there is no de minimis rule.

The same judgment applied the token-use test to pop-up shops in Spain, opened, in the court's view, to maintain the marks rather than to sell. A web page put up in a hurry when a challenge looks likely is open to the same reading.

The four things evidence must show

For EU proceedings, the rule is written down. Article 10(3) of Delegated Regulation 2018/625 says the evidence "shall establish the place, time, extent and nature of use" of the mark for the goods or services relied on. Article 10(4) names the kinds of evidence: packages, labels, price lists, catalogues, invoices, photographs, newspaper advertisements and statements in writing. Web pages are not on that list, but the list gives examples ("such as"), not a closed set. The UK Act does not set out the four questions in the same words, but the Walton factors cover the same ground: what was used, when, where and on what scale.

Here is how a web page bears on each of the four.

Question What a dated capture of your page can show What it cannot show on its own
Nature The mark as it appears, next to the specific goods or services offered That those goods were bought
Time That the page said this on a given date That it said so on any other date
Place Currency, language, delivery countries, the domain Where customers actually were
Extent Very little Sales, orders, visitors

The pattern is clear. A web page is strong evidence of nature and, if it is properly dated, of time. It is partial evidence of place. It says almost nothing about extent, which is usually where proof of use fails.

Why the date is the weak point

A printout of a product page taken today proves what the page says today. The relevant period may have ended two years ago, and a witness who says the site has always looked like this is asking to be taken on trust.

The Wirex v Cryptocarbon [2021] EWHC 617 (IPEC) case shows the cost. It was not a non-use case: the defendants counterclaimed that the claimant's CRYPTOBACK mark was invalid because they had used "cryptoback" first. To prove the earlier use, their witness relied on a video of the website as it then was. At paragraph 17, the judge noted that he "conceded that he could have used the Wayback machine" to show the website as it was before the filing date, "but had not done so". At paragraph 18 the judge said he was "unable to accept any evidence" from that witness about use before the filing date unless it was clearly supported by documents.

A public archive may help if you never kept your own copies, but it may not have crawled the pages you need, on the dates you need, and its captures have their own limits. We cover those in Wayback Machine captures as evidence. The safer course is a record you made yourself, at the time, with dates someone else can check.

How to keep a record that answers a challenge

Start now, for every registered mark you rely on. The five-year window for a future challenge is already running.

  1. List the pages that carry each mark. The home page is rarely enough. Pick the pages that show the mark next to the specific goods or services in the registration: product pages, category pages, service descriptions, price lists. A registration covering ten classes of goods needs pages for the goods you actually sell under it.
  2. Include the pages that show place. Delivery and returns pages, the page that lists the countries you ship to, any page that shows prices in pounds or euros. For an EU mark, pages that show trade in more than one member state help with territorial extent.
  3. Capture each page whole and on a schedule. A full capture keeps the context: the mark in the header, the product, the price, the date the site declared. Capture at regular intervals, and again whenever a product line, price list or brand treatment changes. Our post on how often to capture a web page gives starting intervals. For trade mark purposes, monthly or quarterly captures of each key page across five years give a tribunal a continuous run rather than a gap to probe.
  4. Date each capture independently. A file date on your own server is easy to dispute. A capture that records the address and the time in UTC, with a SHA-256 hash and a timestamp from an outside authority, can be checked by the other side without trusting you.
  5. Pair the pages with evidence of extent. Keep, for the same periods, sales figures by product line and country, a sample of invoices that name the mark, and web analytics showing visits and orders by country. The page shows what was offered; these show that people bought it.
  6. Write down how you did it. Who set up the captures, with what tool, and where the files are kept. Statements in writing are one of the kinds of evidence Article 10(4) names, and Wirex shows what happens to a statement with no documents behind it. Make every claim in yours point to a dated exhibit.
  7. Keep the originals untouched. Annotate copies for the exhibit bundle, never the files themselves.

If a challenge arrives, you can then pick the captures that fall inside the relevant period, show the mark on each class of goods, and set them beside the figures for the same months.

Where Archivepanel fits

Archivepanel captures public web pages, one at a time. A real Chromium browser saves the whole page as a self-contained HTML file with the scripts removed, and stores a preview image, a plain-text version, a WARC file and a manifest with a SHA-256 digest of each file. A note inside the HTML records the address requested, the address reached and when the page was opened and saved, in UTC. As each capture completes, DigiCert signs an RFC 3161 timestamp over the document's digest, which anyone can check with OpenSSL. Snapshots are never rewritten. Tags and notes let you group captures by mark or by class, and the text of two captures of a page can be compared to show what changed.

On the paid plan, schedules capture a page, or every page in a sitemap, at the interval you choose, which is how a five-year run gets built without anyone remembering to do it. It does not capture pages behind a login, so a basket or account page will be out of reach. A capture shows the page as it was served to our browser, so if your site changes prices or delivery options by visitor location, note that alongside it. The DigiCert timestamp is not an eIDAS qualified timestamp. The free tier holds 100 MB.

This is not legal advice. This post describes the Trade Marks Act 1994 as it applies in the UK and the rules for EU trade marks before the EUIPO. National marks in EU member states are governed by their own laws, and what amounts to genuine use depends on the goods, the market and the facts. If you face an opposition or a revocation action, speak to a trade mark attorney before you file anything.

Sources

More from the blog

Keep the version that matters.

Start free with 100 MB of storage. No card required.