Archivepanel

How to preserve evidence of online defamation in England and Wales

A libel claim in England and Wales must start within a year, and the page can change the moment you complain. What to capture first, and the evidence of reach that serious harm needs.

Someone has published something false and damaging about you or your client on a website. The instinct is to write to them straight away and demand it comes down. Do that first and you may get what you asked for: the page disappears, and with it the best evidence of what it said, where, and to how many people.

Preserve first, complain second. This post covers what to capture before anyone is contacted, and why each item matters to a claim. It is about the law of England and Wales. Scotland and Northern Ireland have their own law of defamation.

Why the clock matters more than usual

The usual limit for a claim in tort is six years, under section 2 of the Limitation Act 1980. Defamation allows one. Section 4A of the same Act says no action for libel or slander "shall be brought after the expiration of one year from the date on which the cause of action accrued". The Pre-action Protocol for Media and Communications Claims puts it plainly: the limitation period is "(uniquely) only 1 year in defamation and malicious falsehood cases", and time is "frequently 'of the essence'".

Online, the year usually runs from the first publication. Under the single publication rule in section 8 of the Defamation Act 2013, where a person publishes a statement to the public and later publishes the same or a substantially similar statement, time for the later publication runs from the date of the first. The rule does not apply if the later publication's manner is "materially different", and the factors the court may weigh include "the level of prominence that a statement is given" and "the extent of the subsequent publication".

That gives you three things to pin down: when the statement first appeared, when you found it, and whether it was later republished somewhere more prominent.

The court can let a late claim proceed under section 32A of the 1980 Act if that would be equitable. One of the things it must consider is whether relevant evidence is likely to be unavailable, or "less cogent", because of the delay. Captures made early keep the evidence intact whatever happens to the page, and whenever the claim is brought.

What a claim will ask you to show

Two things decide what is worth capturing.

The letter of claim. Paragraph 3.2 of the protocol says a letter of claim for defamation should identify the publication and the statement complained of, the meaning (imputation) you say it conveys, what is inaccurate, and how it has caused or is likely to cause serious harm under the Defamation Act 2013. Each of those needs something on file.

The serious harm test. Section 1 of the 2013 Act says a statement is not defamatory unless its publication "has caused or is likely to cause serious harm" to the claimant's reputation. For a business that trades for profit, the harm must be "serious financial loss". In Lachaux v Independent Print Ltd [2019] UKSC 27, the Supreme Court held that serious harm is decided by reference to the actual facts about the statement's impact, not only the meaning of the words. The trial judge's finding in that case rested on the meaning, the claimant's situation, the circumstances of publication and the inherent probabilities.

So the meaning of the words is not enough on its own. You need evidence of who could see the statement and what happened when they did, and much of that sits on the page only for as long as the page is up.

What to capture, in order

Do this before you contact the author, the site or anyone else.

  1. The whole page, not a crop. The other side will argue about meaning from everything around the words: the headline, the photo and its caption, the paragraphs either side, any links. Capture the full page as served, from top to bottom. A cropped screenshot of one sentence invites the reply that the rest of the page changes its sense.
  2. The address and the time. Record the exact address, the date and time with a time zone, and any address it redirected to. Note the page's own published date and any "updated" line. These are your first evidence of when time started to run.
  3. The reach. Capture anything on the page that shows how far it travelled: view or share counts, the number of comments, a "most read" list it appears in. Capture the comments themselves, especially any that name you or show a reader recognised you. These go to the facts about impact that Lachaux asks for.
  4. Who is behind it. Capture the author's profile or byline page, the site's "about" or contact page and its terms of use. If you later have to write to the website operator rather than the author, you will need to say where on the site the statement was posted.
  5. Where else it appears. Search for distinctive phrases from the statement and capture each copy you find, separately, with its own address and time. A republication on a larger site may be a fresh publication, and the "materially different" test turns on prominence and extent.
  6. Search results for the name. If the page appears high in a search for your name or your business, capture the results page as well. Note the search engine, the query and the date, since results vary by place and person.
  7. A note of how you did it. Who captured each page, with what tool, from which device, and where the files are stored. Our post on how to preserve a web page as evidence sets out what a capture needs to record to survive a challenge.

Then capture the page again at intervals until the matter is resolved. If it is edited after your complaint, the sequence of versions shows what was said, for how long, and what was changed when you objected.

Pages behind a login

A great deal of defamatory material sits in places that need an account: social media posts, private groups, review platforms that show more to members. Automated capture tools that fetch public pages cannot reach it.

For those, make full-screen screenshots or a screen recording from your own account, showing the address bar, the date and time on the device, and the account you were signed in as. Record what you did in a short note at the time. Have the person who made them ready to give a witness statement about how they were made. A capture whose maker can explain it is worth more than a tidier one nobody can account for.

If you need to write to the website operator

Where the author is anonymous, the site may have a defence under section 5 of the 2013 Act if it shows it did not post the statement. That defence is defeated if the claimant cannot identify the poster, sent the operator a notice of complaint, and the operator did not respond as the regulations require.

A notice of complaint must specify your name, set out the statement and explain why it is defamatory, and specify "where on the website the statement was posted". The Defamation (Operators of Websites) Regulations 2013 add that it must give an email address, the meaning you attribute to the statement, which parts you say are factually inaccurate or opinions not supported by fact, confirmation that you lack sufficient information about the poster to bring proceedings against them, and whether you consent to your name and email address being passed to the poster.

Each of those points is easier to make, and later to prove, with a dated capture of the page in hand.

Mistakes that cost evidence

  • Complaining before capturing. Once you have written, the page can be edited or removed within hours.
  • Saving only a screenshot of the sentence. It loses the context, the address and the reach.
  • Relying on a public archive. The Wayback Machine may never have crawled the page, and its captures carry their own evidential problems. We cover them in Wayback Machine captures as evidence.
  • Editing the files. Annotate a copy, never the original. Keep the original untouched and record its SHA-256 hash.
  • Waiting to see if it blows over. The year runs while you wait.

If your capture is later disputed, the rules on proving it is genuine are set out in web pages as evidence in England and Wales.

Where Archivepanel fits

Archivepanel captures public web pages, one at a time. A real Chromium browser saves the whole page as a self-contained HTML file with the scripts removed, and stores a preview image, a plain-text version, a WARC file and a manifest with a SHA-256 digest of each file. A note inside the HTML records the address requested, the address reached and when the page was opened and saved, in UTC. As each capture completes, DigiCert signs an RFC 3161 timestamp over the document's digest, which anyone can check with OpenSSL. Snapshots are never rewritten, and the text of any two captures of a page can be compared, which shows what was changed after a complaint. See capture.

It does not capture pages behind a login, so most social media posts in private or members-only spaces are out of reach. By default it dismisses cookie banners it recognises before saving, and the record says so. The DigiCert timestamp is not an eIDAS qualified timestamp. The free tier holds 100 MB; scheduled captures, for a page you want recorded at intervals while a dispute runs, are on the paid plan.

This is not legal advice. This post describes the Limitation Act 1980, the Defamation Act 2013 and the pre-action protocol as they apply in England and Wales. Scotland and Northern Ireland have different rules, and whether a statement is defamatory, and what a claim is worth, depends on the facts. If you think you have been defamed, speak to a solicitor early: the one-year limit leaves little room.

Sources

More from the blog

Keep the version that matters.

Start free with 100 MB of storage. No card required.